G.13: Design and evaluate trial-based and free-operant procedures.
Free practice questions for this part of the BCBA, with an explanation for every option.
A BCBA wants to increase how often a child makes spontaneous requests for items during free play, without the therapist presenting instructions. Which approach and measure fit best?
- A. Discrete-trial training measured by latency to respond after the SDLatency after an SD assumes a trainer-presented instruction, which goes against the goal of spontaneity.
- B. A free-operant arrangement (for example, incidental teaching) measured by rate of mands per minuteCorrect. In free-operant arrangements, the learner can respond at any time, so rate is the right measure for spontaneous requests.
- C. Massed trials measured by trials to criterionMassed trials are still trainer-controlled and do not measure spontaneous initiation.
- D. Discrete-trial training measured by percent correct across 10 trialsIn DTT the trainer controls when opportunities occur, so it does not target spontaneous requesting.
In a discrete-trial program for receptive identification, the therapist presents an instruction, waits for a response, delivers a consequence, and pauses briefly before the next trial. Which dimension is most appropriate for summarizing performance?
- A. Percentage of trials with a correct responseCorrect. Discrete trials produce restricted-operant responding, which is usually summarized as percent correct or trials to criterion.
- B. CelerationCeleration describes change in rate over time and is better suited to free-operant data.
- C. Interresponse timeIRT describes time between free-operant responses. It is not used for trial-by-trial accuracy.
- D. Rate of responding per minuteTrial-based responding is limited by how often the trainer presents trials, so rate is less meaningful here.
A vocational trainer sets up a station where an adult can sort recyclables continuously for 20 minutes. Praise is given after every 5 items sorted, and the trainer gives no instructions between items. A colleague asks why this is a free-operant arrangement rather than a trial-based one. Which answer is most accurate?
- A. Reinforcement is given after every response the learner makesReinforcement here is on a ratio schedule (every 5 items), not after every response. In any case, the reinforcement schedule does not decide whether a procedure is free-operant.
- B. Each response is preceded by a discrete instruction and followed by a pauseA discrete instruction followed by a pause describes a trial-based (discrete-trial) procedure, not a free-operant one.
- C. The learner can respond at any time without waiting for a trainer-presented opportunityCorrect. In free-operant arrangements, the learner can respond at any time and as often as they want, with no trainer-delivered cue before each response. Rate is limited only by the learner's own behavior.
- D. The trainer controls the number of opportunities to respondWhen the trainer controls the number of opportunities, the procedure is trial-based. In this setup, the learner controls how many responses occur.