H.3: Select socially valid alternative behavior to be established or increased when a target behavior is to be decreased.
Free practice questions for this part of the BCBA, with an explanation for every option.
An FBA shows that a 2nd grader's calling out during lessons is maintained by teacher attention. Which alternative behavior is the most socially valid choice to strengthen?
- A. Putting his head down on the desk when he wants attentionThis isn't an acceptable classroom behavior, and it doesn't reliably produce attention.
- B. Sitting silently for the entire 45-minute lessonSitting silently is closer to the absence of behavior, doesn't access attention, and is too demanding at first.
- C. Engaging in a preferred fidget activity unrelated to the lessonA fidget activity doesn't serve the attention function, so it won't compete with calling out.
- D. Raising his hand and waiting to be called on, with teacher attention delivered contingentlyCorrect. Hand raising produces the same reinforcer (attention), is appropriate in a classroom, and is likely to be reinforced by the natural classroom contingencies.
A minimally verbal 7-year-old who uses single words throws materials to escape tasks. The team is choosing an initial replacement response for functional communication training. Which choice is best?
- A. Saying, 'Excuse me, may I please have a short break now?'A full sentence is far beyond the child's current verbal repertoire, so the response is effortful and unlikely to compete.
- B. Sitting quietly with hands in lap for 5 minutes to earn a breakThis is closer to the absence of behavior, requires a long delay, and is not a communicative response.
- C. Handing a 'break' card to the instructor, reinforced right away with a brief breakCorrect. A low-effort response that reliably and immediately produces escape is more efficient than throwing, so it is more likely to replace it. Task demands can be increased gradually later.
- D. Completing a 20-minute worksheet without disruption to earn a breakThis response takes much more effort and gets reinforced much later than throwing, so throwing stays the more efficient option.
A 19-year-old in supported employment engages in loud vocal stereotypy at his workstation, and the behavior persists in an alone condition. Which alternative behavior is the most socially valid to establish?
- A. Sitting with hands folded and remaining silentSilence isn't an active alternative and doesn't provide competing stimulation. It is also unlikely to be maintained.
- B. Humming quietly every few minutesHumming may still disrupt coworkers and is close to the target behavior topographically.
- C. Leaving the workstation for a break whenever stereotypy occursBreaks contingent on stereotypy could reinforce the problem behavior, and they reduce productive work time.
- D. Listening to preferred music through headphones while workingCorrect. Headphone music provides matched auditory stimulation in a way that is acceptable in a workplace, so it can compete with automatically reinforced vocal stereotypy.